Why Most Marketers Get Social Media Content Writing Wrong (And How to Fix It)

Introduction

As a marketer, you've probably been there: You spend hours crafting the "perfect" social media post—polished copy, eye-catching visuals, and strategic hashtags—only for it to get crickets.

Meanwhile, you see competitors and influencers getting massive engagement with content that looks... well, kinda casual. What gives?

The truth is, most marketers misunderstand what actually works on social media today. Let me show you three critical mistakes brands make—with real examples of what to do instead.

Be Creative


Mistake #1: Selling Instead of Helping

The Flawed Approach:

A B2B SaaS company posts:
"Our project management software is the best! Sign up for a demo today!" (with a generic stock image of people smiling at computers)

Why It Fails:

  • Zero value for scrollers

  • All ask, no give

  • Looks like every other ad

The Fix – Value-First Content:

Same company could post:
"5 Signs Your Team Needs a Better Project Management System"

  • Bullet list of pain points (missed deadlines, chaotic Slack threads)

  • No direct sales pitch

  • Ends with: "Struggling with these? We've got a solution—DM us to chat."

Real Example That Worked:

Ahrefs grew massively by creating free, actionable SEO guides before ever mentioning their tool. Their "SEO for Beginners" blog post brought in thousands of leads.

Mistake #2: Corporate Perfection Over Relatable Reality

The Flawed Approach:
A fashion brand posts:
"Our new summer collection embodies effortless elegance. Shop now!" (with a stiff, studio-shot model)

Why It Fails:

  • Feels like a catalog

  • Zero emotional connection

  • Forgettable among 100 identical posts

The Fix – Authentic Storytelling:

Same brand could post:
"Meet Maria, our pattern designer. She spent 6 months perfecting this dress's drape—swipe to see her first 10 failed prototypes!"

  • BTS footage of real struggles

  • Employee spotlight builds trust

  • Shows the human behind the product

Real Example That Worked:
Glossier built a cult following by featuring real customers' selfies instead of professional models. Their #GlossierRep posts generated UGC worth millions in marketing value.

Mistake #3: Talking At People Instead of With Them

The Flawed Approach:

A consulting firm posts:
"We help businesses scale efficiently. Visit our website!"

Why It Fails:

  • Monologue, not dialogue

  • No reason to engage

  • Algorithm ignores it

The Fix – Conversation Starters:

Same firm could post:
*"Founders: What's your #1 scaling challenge?
A) Hiring the right team
B) Cash flow management
C) Systems breaking at 20+ employees
Comment below—we'll share tailored advice!"*

Real Example That Worked:
HubSpot's LinkedIn poll about marketing challenges got 400+ comments, massively boosting their reach. They later turned responses into a lead-generating ebook.

The Golden Rule: Social Media Isn't Media, It's Social

Bad Strategy:
❌ Post = Digital Billboard
Winning Strategy:
✅ Post = Coffee Chat with Someone Interesting

More Real-World Examples:

  • Duolingo's TikTok: Went viral by being weird (meme-friendly owl) instead of corporate

  • Starbucks' UGC: 80% of their content features customer photos with drinks

  • Zapier's Threads: Their "AMA with our CTO" got 10X more engagement than product announcements

Your Turn

Which of these resonates most with you?

  1. "We definitely post too many promotions..."

  2. "Our content feels stiff, but leadership wants it 'professional'"

  3. "I never know how to get people to comment!"

Let me know in the comments—I'll share specific tips for your situation. #SocialMediaMarketing

Why This Version Works Better:

  • Concrete examples prove these aren't just theories

  • Industry variety (SaaS, fashion, consulting) makes it broadly applicable

  • Social proof with real brand results builds credibility

Comments

Post a Comment